Ratings

[Strikegold]

Is anyone up for a ratings thread to rate the players for every match. ?

 

[Yid]

Is anyone up for a ratings thread to rate the players for every match. ?

Do it in the match thread...?

 

[Strikegold]

Do it in the match thread...?

If there are enough contributors that might get a bit congested and mixed in. I have run ratings threads for 4 seasons in varying formats and an easy to use form for each match provides clarity and the least effort. I will need help with the layout and format as I'm not great at that stuff.
It's partly a data building process but also a test and measure of our opinions. I collate media and web ratings for a comparison and produce an average across usually 20 ratings in total including forums, newspapers, Football London, Sky, Spurs Web, 90 minutes and so on.

There has to be be enough people up for it although I can import ratings from other forums, I would prefer 10 per match from this one.

 

[Dorset]

What @Yid said - or do it in another thread so I can swerve it, not interested.

 

[Strikegold]

What @Yid said - or do it in another thread so I can swerve it, not interested.

Thanks for your input.

 

[spurs2rise]

I personally would rather do a a 3-2-1 or 5-4-3-2-1 vote for best players in each game as opposed to the whole XI.

A bit like a "Proper Spursy Player of the Season"... They'll all be clamouring over each other to win that award

 

[Strikegold]

I personally would rather do a a 3-2-1 or 5-4-3-2-1 vote for best players in each game as opposed to the whole XI.

A bit like a "Proper Spursy Player of the Season"... They'll all be clamouring over each other to win that award

Soon I will be posting the entire season average ratings for our players. That will provide a 123 type table. There are other factors to consider on the player of the season such as number of games played and consistency of performance. Vdv missed a fair few games so although our best player.....did he contribute the most to our seasons standing ?

 

[Strikegold]

Previous seasons ratings ( 22/23 ) compiled from the media / web and Spurs forums members ratings.
1. Kane.... 6.63, 47 games
2.Hojbjer ...6.19, 43
3. Kulu.......6.19, 27
4. Davies...5.94, 31
5.Lenglet...5.89, 32
6.Royal.......5.88, 26
7. Romero..5.87, 31
8.Dier..........5.83, 39
9. Lloris......5.81, 30
10. Perisic .5.74, 33
11. Son.......5.53, 42
21 / 22 averages
1. Dier............6.65
2. Romero.....6.58
3.Lloris..........6.45
4. Skip/Son...6.37
5.Kane...........6.25
6. Hojbjerg....6.21
7. Sanchez....6.18
8.Moura.........6.17
9. Royal..........6.08
10.Davies.......5.91
20/21
1. Kane.............6.63
2. Hojbjerg.......6.41
3.Toby...............6.35
4. Lloris.............6.22
5.Ndombele......6.20
6. Son................6.19
7.Dele Ali...........6.18
8.Lo Celso.........6.16
9. Dier................6.10
10.Lamela.........6.08
11.Aurier............5.86
12. Davies.........5.84
All are compiled from generally a combination of 10 media/ Web ratings and 10 Spurs forum ratings, so across 20 different opinions.
Players included were all starters, not subs.
Players also had to meet the requirenent of a minimum number of games....usually half of the games played as a minimum..

 

[Strikegold]

This seasons ratings averages I am going to look at in 2 different ways. The pure rating and total rating contribution including but excluding Vicario who played every game.
Pure ratings with number of games in second column.
1. Vdv.............7.06, 29
2. Maddison..6.94, 26
3. Romero......6.72, 33
4. Porro..........6.65, 37
5.Udogie.........6.58,.30
6. Vicario........6.55, 41
7. Sarr.............6.44, 27
8. Son..............6.36, 34
9. Kulusevs.....6.30, 31
10. Richarlis....6.28, 21
11. Bissoum....6.10, 25
12. Johnson....5.87, 25

 

[Strikegold]

A table reflecting total rating contribution with number of games in second column.
1. Vicario.....268.56, 41
2. Porro........246.29, 37
3. Romero....221.98, 33
4. Son...........216.37, 34
5. Vdv...........204.78, 29
6. Udogie.....197.65, 30
7. Kulu.........195.59, 31
8. Maddis....180.44, 26
9. Sarr..........174.08, 27
10. Bisso.....152.65, 25
11. Johnso..145.86, 25
12. Richi......131.95, 21

 

[Strikegold]

My question is....who should be the player with the most credit ? the one who rated highest over the games they played or the one who contributed the biggest total ?

 

[Strikegold]

Congratulations to Micky Vdv on cracking the magic 7 for the season. It's the first time since I started producing seasons averages over 5 years ago. Kane even with a good season didn't hit the 7, but he did play more games in doing so.

 

[SpiderSpurs]

Oh wow, you twat.