Financial irregularities...

[Havocc]

A points reduction may save Tottenham from relegation

 

[USspur]

A points reduction may save Tottenham from relegation

All in all I think this will send Everton down

 

[jaxdermot]

it's kinda like this thread belongs in Con SPURicies

 

[Havocc]

Loan bid for Haaland in January

 

[ClemFandango]

The amount of hyperbole about this case at the moment is quite absurd. One thinks it'll take at least five to six more years before any kind of punishment will be seen, another thinks that the EFL will join with the Premier League in whatever they decide so City could be kicked out of all of football.

But then the main point people are making is that Everton were deducted 6 points for ONE financial breach and City have just been found guilty of 114 so it needs to be proportionate.

 

[Dave]

The amount of hyperbole about this case at the moment is quite absurd. One thinks it'll take at least five to six more years before any kind of punishment will be seen, another thinks that the EFL will join with the Premier League in whatever they decide so City could be kicked out of all of football.

But then the main point people are making is that Everton were deducted 6 points for ONE financial breach and City have just been found guilty of 114 so it needs to be proportionate.

But "Apparantly " it's only really 3 or 4 charges, and there's loads of variations within those charges. So if Everton were deducted 6 points, City would get 20/24 points...or to put it simply...no European football for one season...

 

[jaxdermot]

Loan bid for Haaland in January

straight swap for Slowanke

 

[J.spurs]

I don't think they'll get away with a rap on the knuckles, but whatever happens to them, they're going to be facing one loss of chance lawsuit after another for the next 20 years. For example, we finished one spot outside the CL four times during the period when the violations took place. I heard a football finance guy saying clubs get a £40 million windfall just from qualifying for CL. So that's almost £150 million from our club alone. Then you've got the teams they beat in cup finals, players missing out on bonuses, and on and on and on.

 

[BrooklynYid]

My take on the intra club lawsuits for opportunity loss is that they're bullshit. The PL has been lax on these things for years and City just took advantage better that the rest. Of course they shoild be severely punished but i do think it's a bit ridiculous for clubs to claim titles, higher placement because of another clubs supposed financial breaches. The issue is that the PL allowed a wealthy nation to own a club. And what we thought would happen did happen. All of the fallout from that decision was fully deserved. And i am sure many of the big clubs now crying went along with it for hope it drove up their clubs' valuations. All of the superleague clubs shoudl just shut up about it. Though i do think they should dock Everton again just for giggles.

 

[Dave]

My take on the intra club lawsuits for opportunity loss is that they're bullshit. The PL has been lax on these things for years and City just took advantage better that the rest. Of course they shoild be severely punished but i do think it's a bit ridiculous for clubs to claim titles, higher placement because of another clubs supposed financial breaches. The issue is that the PL allowed a wealthy nation to own a club. And what we thought would happen did happen. All of the fallout from that decision was fully deserved. And i am sure many of the big clubs now crying went along with it for hope it drove up their clubs' valuations. All of the superleague clubs shoudl just shut up about it. Though i do think they should dock Everton again just for giggles.

It's a complete mess. The rest of the big European leagues are rolling around laughing at the PL, and justifiably so...
I think it'll have to be swift rejection of any appeal and straight to sentencing. Which should be 100 point deduction and an earth shattering fine...ie: relegation and a serious dent in the wallet.
Any other claims from other clubs regarding loss of earnings etc will be either taken from the massive fine they enforce on City and equally given to the 29 clubs that occupied the Premier league for that period or they'll just tell them all to do one.
I'd wager the latter.

This is all of their doing. They knew what City were doing. How could they not.
This might take the PL years to recover from this but the flip side means it might actually even the scales a little for other clubs trying to compete.

Interesting times ahead.

 

[SpursStone]

I don't think they'll get away with a rap on the knuckles, but whatever happens to them, they're going to be facing one loss of chance lawsuit after another for the next 20 years. For example, we finished one spot outside the CL four times during the period when the violations took place. I heard a football finance guy saying clubs get a £40 million windfall just from qualifying for CL. So that's almost £150 million from our club alone. Then you've got the teams they beat in cup finals, players missing out on bonuses, and on and on and on.

That could be huge if a few players are successful in getting missed payments, the gates will smash open

 

[J.spurs]

My take on the intra club lawsuits for opportunity loss is that they're bullshit. The PL has been lax on these things for years and City just took advantage better that the rest. Of course they shoild be severely punished but i do think it's a bit ridiculous for clubs to claim titles, higher placement because of another clubs supposed financial breaches. The issue is that the PL allowed a wealthy nation to own a club. And what we thought would happen did happen. All of the fallout from that decision was fully deserved. And i am sure many of the big clubs now crying went along with it for hope it drove up their clubs' valuations. All of the superleague clubs shoudl just shut up about it. Though i do think they should dock Everton again just for giggles.

Paying clubs for opportunity loss, whether ordered by courts or commissions, may be the only real punishment they receive. There's lot of precedent: just this summer Everton had to pay Burnley £35 million.

 

[Yid]

I think the Premier are in trouble...

It'll come out that they were complicit and when it does the entire leagues integrity disappears overnight with all the finance it brings as well as potentially all the finances it probably ever had as sponsors look to sue them for damaging their brand...

Can you retrospectively sue for damages to reputation...? IDFK, but fuck the Prem, they're as bent as the fucking rest...

Viva la revolution...

 

[J.spurs]

That could be huge if a few players are successful in getting missed payments, the gates will smash open

I don't know if anything has ever come of it, but some of Southampton's own players were considering suing the club for missed opportunity at promotion bonuses, which I guess are pretty significant parts of their contracts at Championship level.

 

[BrooklynYid]

Paying clubs for opportunity loss, whether ordered by courts or commissions, may be the only real punishment they receive. There's lot of precedent: just this summer Everton had to pay Burnley £35 million.

The slippery slope there is that could end the PL. Once the mudslinging starts, i feel there will be lots and lots of mud laying around. I don't think any of these clubs are truly honest brokers. Really, they'd be foolish if they were.

But i did just read a comment on a Times article that had a brilliant punishment. The idea is that you dock them say around 15 to 20 points for each of their next 7 seasons in the PL. Would almost certainly make it impossible for them to win, and Europe would be a stretch at best. A one year demotion to the Championship and they'll be back kn CL in 2 years. Basically, reset them to 2008. No sure if this idea is legal under FA rules but it is genius. Oh, and make them sell. Never should have been allowed to begin with.

 

[jaxdermot]

Well this sucks . is watching the Premier League akin to watching WWF wraslin or LIV Golf (not that I watch either) Or is it even exactly like the coveted World Cup .....

I hope that it's Just Man Shity involved, but I feel most professional teams believe if you ain't cheating you ain't trying....

Also we spent £300 Millionish "legally" this year and we're sitting in last place, so at least those Manchester cunt cheats understand how to waste money, I'll give them that....

At least the US soccer youth system ( which my daughter plays for ) is not a money making scheme....

sigh ........

 

[Ted the Yid]

The slippery slope there is that could end the PL.

Would that be a bad thing? If it were proven that the current governing body was not fit to manage the English League, then they would need to be replaced. Under the current UK Prime Minister, I would not be surprised if the government intervened and restructured the priorities to be more in line with genuine fans Vs profit, although nothing very revolutionary.

 

[Dave]

Would that be a bad thing? If it were proven that the current governing body was not fit to manage the English League, then they would need to be replaced. Under the current UK Prime Minister, I would not be surprised if the government intervened and restructured the priorities to be more in line with genuine fans Vs profit, although nothing very revolutionary.

A perfect opportunity for the league to perform a "Correction" for everybody's sake.

 

[Yid]

That would require a full blown scandal at the Premier League... And so much political capital that, that I don't know if any politician would take it on... Unless the alternative was the end of English top flight football...

And then it's be an economic decision...

And that's different...

 

[J.spurs]

Well this sucks . is watching the Premier League akin to watching WWF wraslin or LIV Golf (not that I watch either)

What’s interesting is that the saudis are pulling out of LIV, which makes me wonder if the City owners might not think about doing the same thing.

 

[ClemFandango]

It's always interesting watching "that" game against QPR where they give the ball back to City immediately after scoring. Knowing what we know now, it certainly paints it in an "interesting" light.